Why E-Coat and Black Oxide Are Becoming Obsolete for Precision Sheet Metal Finishing (Updated for 2026)

Last updated on February 11th, 2026 at 12:49 pm

There was a time when electro-coat (e-coat) and black oxide were go-to methods for precision sheet metal finishing. In today’s manufacturing landscape, however, they are far less common than they once were.

Here, we’ll examine why e-coat & black oxide treatments are used less frequently today and explore the benefits of the alternative finishing methods we recommend.

The Fall of E-Coat and Black Oxide

Metal fabrication shops once commonly provided e-coat & black oxide finishing for parts requiring corrosion resistance. As the drawbacks of these finish options became more apparent and more efficient finishing technologies became available, fewer shops continued offering them.

Highly regulated, chemical-intensive processes

Black oxide and e-coat finishing processes involve aggressive chemical treatments that require strict handling procedures, environmental controls, and regulatory compliance. Managing these processes safely adds operational complexity for finishing vendors.

As a result, many shops have chosen to discontinue these services. While some legacy drawings still call out black oxide or e-coat, vendor availability is far more limited than it once was.

Finish variability and process sensitivity

Not only are black oxide and e-coat chemical processes, they can also be more process-sensitive than modern alternatives. E-coat can produce inconsistent film thickness if not tightly controlled, and black oxide requires precise chemistry and post-treatment sealing to perform properly.

We once received parts back from a vendor who had treated them with black oxide, only to find the parts compromised during inspection. Although the issue stemmed from vendor process control rather than the finishing method itself, highly chemical treatments introduce additional variables that increase overall risk compared to today’s leading finishing methods.

Limited color flexibility

As its name suggests, black oxide is only available in black, and most vendors offer limited color options for e-coat. When color matching, branding, or aesthetic requirements are important, neither method provides the flexibility available with modern finishing systems.

Superior Finishing Methods in the Modern Metal Fabrication Shop

Precision sheet metal finishing has advanced significantly in recent years. Today, we most often recommend powder coating and anodizing as safe, durable, and versatile alternatives to black oxide and e-coat.

Anodize

Anodizing provides enhanced corrosion resistance for aluminum components and creates a durable oxide layer integrated into the surface of the metal. It can also electrically insulate parts when required. Available in a wide variety of colors, anodizing produces a smooth, consistent finish suitable for both functional and cosmetic applications.

Powder coat

Powder coating is a dry powder finish applied using an electrostatic process and then cured under heat to form a durable coating. Available in a broad range of textures and more than 6,500 colors, powder coating offers excellent corrosion resistance, color flexibility, and efficient application for production runs.

Fun fact: In certain applications, anodizing and powder coating can be used on the same aluminum part. For example, anodizing may be applied first for corrosion resistance, followed by powder coating for specific color or aesthetic requirements.

In addition to powder coating and anodizing, other finishing methods may be considered depending on material type, corrosion requirements, and appearance:

1. Zinc Plating

Zinc plating applies a thin zinc layer to steel parts to improve corrosion resistance. It is cost-effective, suitable for high volumes, and available in finishes such as clear, yellow, or black. High-strength steels may require hydrogen relief baking after plating.

2. Conversion Coatings

Conversion coatings chemically treat a metal surface to improve corrosion resistance or paint adhesion. Examples include chromate conversion for aluminum and phosphate coatings for steel. These treatments are often used as base layers before painting or powder coating.

3. Electropolishing

Electropolishing removes a thin surface layer from stainless steel parts to create a smooth, clean finish. It improves corrosion resistance and is often used in hygienic or high-purity environments.

4. Dip-Spin Coating

Dip-spin coating immerses parts in a zinc-rich coating and spins off excess material to ensure uniform coverage. It is commonly used for small hardware and fasteners.

5. Black Zinc Plating

Black zinc plating provides improved corrosion resistance compared to black oxide while achieving a similar dark appearance, making it a practical alternative for fasteners and hardware.

When selecting a finishing method, factors such as base material, corrosion exposure, mechanical requirements, appearance, and vendor availability should all be considered. Working with an experienced sheet metal fabrication partner helps ensure the correct process is specified from the start.

6 Tips for Designing Powder Coated Sheet Metal Parts

POWDER COATING

With over two decades of experience in powder coating, we’ve learned that a little bit of foresight yields superior outcomes. Here are our top tips for powder coated sheet metal parts.

Read the 6 Tips

Consolidate Your Supply Chain with Approved Sheet Metal

At ASM, we coordinate anodizing and powder coating services through trusted members of our vendor network. When you work with our metal fabrication shop, you gain the convenience of partnering with a single source to fabricate your sheet metal parts and manage finishing on your behalf.

If your drawings specify e-coat or black oxide, we will typically recommend a more widely available alternative such as anodizing or powder coating. These options generally provide improved consistency, broader aesthetic flexibility, and shorter lead times due to stronger vendor availability.

Need precision sheet metal parts fast? Request a quote today!

Sheet Metal E-Coat and Black Oxide FAQ

Why are e-coat and black oxide treatments no longer popular in metal fabrication?

E-coat and black oxide involve highly toxic chemicals, posing risks to workers, the environment, and regulatory compliance. Moreover, they often result in inconsistent finishes or damage to parts. As safer and more versatile alternatives emerged, their popularity declined.

What drawbacks did black oxide and e-coat finishing processes present?

Both methods involved hazardous chemicals, leading to safety concerns and environmental impact. Additionally, they were prone to producing unpredictable finishes, and black oxide, if applied incorrectly, could harm a part’s chemical structure.

What limitations did e-coat and black oxide have in terms of color options?

Black oxide was exclusively available in black, while e-coat offered only a limited selection of colors. When specific colors were essential for parts, neither of these finishing methods provided ideal solutions.

What are the recommended modern alternatives to e-coat and black oxide finishing methods?

Anodize and powder coat are suggested as superior alternatives. Anodize offers higher corrosion resistance, a safer process, and a wide array of color choices. Meanwhile, powder coat boasts versatility with over 6,500 color options and various textures.

How can one streamline the process of obtaining sheet metal parts with preferred finishing methods?

Partnering with a fabrication shop like ASM allows you to consolidate services. ASM outsources anodizing and powder coating to trusted vendors, offering convenience by coordinating both fabrication and finishing services through a single source. Additionally, they recommend alternatives like anodize or powder coat for superior outcomes and faster turnaround times.